• Hi Guest: Welcome to TRIBE, the online home of TRIBE MAGAZINE. If you'd like to post here, or reply to existing posts on TRIBE, you first have to register. Join us!

Kraftwerk vs Coldplay

A

Andrew Duke

TRIBE Member
Just heard that the rumors are true:
Coldplay's "Talk" (their new single)
nicks the riff from Kraftwerk's "Computer
Love" (apparently done legally):

I hadn't heard the Coldplay track that uses the Kraftwerk riff till this thread
came up on the 313 list (had only heard rumors).
If anyone wants to compare:
http://www.last.fm/music/Coldplay/_/Talk
(click on the green triangle to the left of "Talk")
and if you don't have your copy of Kraftwerk's
Computer Love handy:
http://www.artistdirect.com/nad/store/artist/album/0,,116410,00.html
(but listen to the Windows Media clip cos the RealPlayer clip uses a
different part of the song).
My wife (knows Kraftwerk, not Coldplay) just heard me play the
comparison and she said "Kraftwerk should sue". I hope Kraftwerk
get tons of royalties from this.
Andrew
 
Cannabis Seed Wedding Bands
C

case sensitive

TRIBE Member
It's almost justified, because Coldplay got seriously ripped off themselves.

Compare

Coldplay -The Scientist - released 2002, and one of their greatest tracks

to

Sum41 - Pieces - released 2004, almost identical in terms of song structure and theme.

They actually played a mashup of these two tunes on the EDGE, and it was fucking creepy, just another good reason to hate on the pop-punkers from Ajax.
 
C

case sensitive

TRIBE Member
Originally posted by docta seuss
not really.
Click to expand...

I guess it depends on your musical preferences really.

It also gets back to the old sample argument, in hip-hop, where do you draw the line for example?

bigger discussion that this isolated incidence I would say.
 
tribe cannabis accessories silver grinders
T

todiefor

TRIBE Promoter
I fail to see why there is an issue if Kraftwerk agreed. It's about the biggest compliment a musicina can get, no?
 
V

vveerrgg

TRIBE Promoter
bands and artists bite musical bits from each other all the time. I use to think it was wrong.... but you gotta admit... Coldplay took that riff and used it in a totally different way to the original.. so i don't feel so miffed about it.

its when they rip a sample and use it in almost the same context that really pisses me off. Then there's hell to pay!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top