Originally posted by Littlest Hobo
I've read many clubs in New York will confiscate smokes from patrons when they enter. In New York health inspectors can fine you for having ashtrays on premises. This is because the venue gets fined. Whether or not the patron gets fined is irrevelant.
Club can confiscate whatever they want. They also do this with water bottles. It makes sense to fine venues that are supposed to be complying with a non-smoking by-law for having ashtrays on the premises. I doubt the clubs got shut down for it.
Please find me at least one news report that show that restaurants have been (in your words) SHUT DOWN because someone was smoking inside. As in, I am eating dinner on March 6th and smoking, a smoking inspector comes in and see me and instantly shuts down the restaurant on March 6th for the rest of the night. That is what you were talking about right. People having to leave Boa because someone was smoking a cigarette inside.
Now with tobacco, this will get interesting. The only incentive bar owners have to ensure non-smoking on premises is if the bar owner themselves are held liable. Otherwise they would have opened their own non-smoking establishment long ago, due to the overwhelming demand for these such establishments. Smokers don't give a shit about the bylaw if they themselves are the only one who will get the fine and the owner doesn't boot them. IIRC, Toronto (or somewhere else - I'm not sure) made restaurants smoke-free a while back except owners kept passing out ashtrays and said 'watch out for the inspectors." Making sense yet?
No, your claim that Boa or an event would be instantaneously shut down because someone was found smoking inside still does not make sense to me.
Explain it.