1. Hi Guest: Welcome to TRIBE, Toronto's largest and longest running online community. If you'd like to post here, or reply to existing posts on TRIBE, you first have to register on the forum. You can register with your facebook ID or with an email address. Join us!

Catholic Church to open its doors to gay priests

Discussion in 'Politics (deprecated)' started by docta seuss, Oct 8, 2005.

  1. docta seuss

    docta seuss TRIBE Member

    CBC News

    A Vatican document expected to be made public soon says the Church will allow gay men who have lived chastely for three years to be candidates for the priesthood.

    The document, which has been in the works for three years will update Vatican policy which up until now made clear that homosexuals should be barred from the priesthood.

    A senior official with the Vatican, who requested anonymity because the document has not yet been released said the new policy will permit candidates who have lived a chaste life for at least three years before their admission to the seminary.

    The Italian weekly Panorama said in its Friday editions that Pope Benedict XVI approved the document during the summer.

    In a similar report Friday, the National Catholic Reporter said seminary officials will be asked to exercise "prudential judgement."

    Vatican teaching holds that homosexual acts are "intrinsically disordered." The Church, however, says that homosexuals should be treated with compassion and dignity.

    The issue has long been a subject of debate at the Vatican.

    An American homosexual priest, speaking on condition of anonymity because he feared reprisal from church leaders, said if the reports are "it will be the first time that the church will have formally said that gay men have been and can be accepted by seminaries."
  2. docta seuss

    docta seuss TRIBE Member

    i can honestly say i didn't see that one coming..
  3. enjiro

    enjiro TRIBE Member

    yes. I'm having a hard time beliving this one.. I mean, they're suddenly going to reverse a 2000 year old decision? Older, even, given the previous jewish states didn't exactally embrace homosexualism either.

    Hehe.. I want to hear Bush's response to this one if it actually happens.
  4. deafplayer

    deafplayer TRIBE Member

    gays before women?
    and there are already thousands of gays in the ministry...
  5. Bass-Invader

    Bass-Invader TRIBE Member


  6. ndrwrld

    ndrwrld TRIBE Member

  7. deafplayer

    deafplayer TRIBE Member

    yeah i didnt mean to imply that... im just saying, the people in the church are doing this, including many who are gay
    it seems like of weird that they're allowing homosexuality before being a woman (which never got you sentenced to hell as far as i know)... but maybe it shouldnt be, considering its an organization consisting entirely of men who have renounced sexuality... apparently, they sympathize w/ homosexuality before that wicked gender that got us kicked out of eden
    i dont think youre even allowed to teach in catholic schools here if youre gay (at least until recently)
  8. AdRiaN

    AdRiaN TRIBE Member

    This is nothing new.

    I went through Catholic school learning that many passages of the Bible were purely symbolic, particularly the creation story. I imagine these documents were only issued to reinforce existing Church doctrine rather than present a new position.

    Here's what the Catechism of the Roman Catholic Church says about creation:

    "The question about the origins of the world and of man has been the object of many scientific studies which have splendidly enriched our knowledge of the age and dimensions of the cosmos, the development of life-forms and the appearance of man. These discoveries invite us to even greater admiration for the greatness of the Creator, prompting us to give him thanks for all his works and for the understanding and wisdom he gives to scholars and researchers."

    In other words, the Church has accepted evolutionary theory for quite some time already.
  9. ~atp~

    ~atp~ TRIBE Member

    I love how you can just arbitrarily entreat some Biblical statements or concepts as merely "symbolic" allowing contradictory information to coincide with "God's word", while other statements are observed as "literal", the breaking of which deserves nothing less than complete atonement or a life of condemnation and purgatory.

    I wish I could approach other problems that way! My house is burning? No, no, that's symbolic. :)
  10. Ditto Much

    Ditto Much TRIBE Member

    Yes but lets go a little easy on them. First they are picking Darwin over creationism or "Intelligent Design" as it has been relabeled. This alone makes me happy and clearly defines a separation between a Christian right and a catholic one. In a political sense this closes the door on at least one major stupidity.

    This has been one of my biggest sticking points with the Catholic Church (a group I support more times than I should) gay marriage, divorce, abortion, euthanasia, and traffic tickets are clearly secular and should remain that way. If you want to preach a higher morality to your followers GO AHEAD!! But lets not base secular law on this standard.

    Next off...

    Finally they're saying the bitch wasn't a virgin. Christ ever since grade 6 this made sense to me and I was late in getting it. There is no prophecy and women who bare children simply aren't virgins by the definition of the word. The entire thing was some sick joke added in long after the fact for socio political reasons.

    Personally its one of the few books of the bible I kind of liked. I've read it to me 8 year old nephew he was scared shitless! Its better than most fireside spook stories and without its fantastic imagery what would heavy medal music be, chirst Satanists would have nothing if not for the book of Revelation.

    Honestly though I'm impressed, I expected this pope to be much less liberal and the fact that the wall is crumbling a little makes me happy. If over the next 50 years the Roman Catholic Church begins focusing on aid and development in the third world and not literal interpretations they may still hold some relevance. Catholic guilt should be used as the tool it was intended for and we no longer need creationist bullshit, virgins, and books of the coming floods of lava.

    God isn't sending an apocalypse there is no judgment day stop living for the end of the world that isn't fucking coming.
  11. Ditto Much

    Ditto Much TRIBE Member

    We still thank god for it, but we agree his/her link to it is tenuous at best and if s/he does exist s/he probably didn't do anything.

    I honestly like this approach. Galileo wasn't a heretic because of what he said and published, he was a heretic for doing it on the payroll of the Roman Catholic Church and releasing it without there permission. The earth really does orbit around the sun, our sun is only one of a magnitude of others.

    Thank god for it, s/he had nothing to do with it but hey threes nobody else to thank so god it is.
  12. Ditto Much

    Ditto Much TRIBE Member

    Ahh and here goes that whole burning in hell for adultry! fuken eh who'd have guessed all the Jezebel's can be thankfull they aren't to be taken literally anymore.

    christ I've never wanted to s/he a quote before this one...
  13. AdRiaN

    AdRiaN TRIBE Member

    The Catholic Church has never been centred around the Bible. The Church was founded as a direct continuation of Christ's mission on Earth through Saint Peter and his successors (i.e., the Pope), which makes it quite different than almost every other Christian denomination.
  14. ~atp~

    ~atp~ TRIBE Member

    Yah, don't even get me started on Catholicism.

    In keeping with this thread, I think it is great that the Church is able to reconcile some of its differences and keep up with "secular" society (not to mention progressive thought), but such facts do not change the flawed premises on which the Church stands.
  15. dora

    dora TRIBE Member

    That's the first thing I though of... I applaud these "contemporary" moves made by the Catholic church, but gays are aloud to enter priesthood and women still aren't?

    They're revoking the Adam & Eve story as symbolic and yet we're still bitches?!? WTF.

    but I guess some movement is better than none at all... The gays will eventually overrule and bring on their fag hags into the priesthood!
  16. judge wopner

    judge wopner TRIBE Member

    remember as much as you or i dont agree with the catholic church they are very much a part of many cultures and are considered a source of guidance and morality. (how ever misguided their blueprint for it may seem)

    i give them credit for this move as it seems to me in keeping with the whole notion that jesus loves everyone and its all good among people and blah blah blah.

    the reason i think protestant streams of christianity seem to be gaining the most ground over the last decades their more open nature of many protestant sects.

    women or gay preists, birth control is ok, more simple and humble church institutions, a mesage more of tolerance than doctrine and attacks against other faiths which mark catholoism and islam sermons alike too often for my liking.

    i think islam needs to continue in its path of reformation like the catholic church is with these types of acts as both have long held homophobic stances that have not served them well in an increasingly open society.

    now if only preists could have sex , then the catholics would be cooking!!
  17. Colm

    Colm TRIBE Member


    The document should be released this weekend.

    Re: dittomuch - Because the Church has said certain parts of the Bible shouldn't be take literally, does not mean it has decided the entire Bible is now merely a symbol of days & doctrine past. Things like the Virgin Birth & adultery, for example, are matters of infallible doctrine around which the Church is centred. Is it unbelievable? Of course! This is the Catholic Church we're talking about.

    Re: The Chuch scandal.
    80% of the cases were of a homosexual nature. The majority of these cases dealt not with a priest molesting a pre-pubescent boy, but with adolescents and adult men. This I think is one of the reasons why the new document will only reaffirm the ban on homosexual men from the priesthood and not introduce some sort of extraordinairy qualifying process.

    Re: judge wopner
    The protestant streams of Christianity did enjoy a popular moment from the 1960s to the 1990s. But their heyday has now passed and the orthodox Churches have now eclipsed their 'liberal' counterparts in conversions, membership and overall vitality. The issues which seem to occupy everyone's mind these days, are in fact closed questions for the Church. Birth control, priestesses, trusteeism etc will never find a home in Catholicism, even if many North American and European Catholics believe they should. The Pope, bishops or whomever, cannot simply change doctrine because secular society deems it necessary. If you want a church that does, the Episcopalian & Canadian Anglican congregations are more than happy to welcome you in.
    Last edited: Nov 4, 2005
  18. judge wopner

    judge wopner TRIBE Member

    i disagree, the largest catholic dioceese in the US dont touch the large baptist churches of the south.

    while alot of attention has gone to the cahtolics and hard core fundamentalists, they still remain by and large a minority to the larger protestant population of the US and Canada.

    i assume by orthodox you dont mean greek/eastern orthodox as th eonly reason they are getting more members is because guys like me see their church as a great way to meet yugoslavian chicks.
  19. Colm

    Colm TRIBE Member


    you're right tho - i should replace 'orthodox Churches' with 'Catholic Church', given our discussion was centred on America, and not the entire world.

    Catholic Church in the US: 66 Million members. True, there are more protestants in America and Canada. The problem there is the 35,000 protestant denominations at work in North America - making our comparison squabble infinitesimally more difficult to resolve.

Share This Page