I would never say Aphrodite has always been a bad producer, I don't think many people would. He used to produce some of the best tunes around, just look at Bomber, Arsonist, etc... and he's still technically a good producer. His sound is very clean and like you said, he has his own sound.
That doesn't mean I can't criticise him though. In my opinion, he has neglected the creative aspect of producing music in the past few years, and has simply aimed at producing mass-marketable material. I don't think he's producing music because he just loves it and has to express himself creatively anymore. I think he's doing it to make money these days.
Now, whether you argue that that is a necessary evil or not is a whole other debate that I won't get into. It's still my opinion though.
Rob